TL;DR - What You Need to Know Before You Start
- Anyone can use a butt plug. The anus has dense nerve endings regardless of your gender, anatomy, or sexual orientation.
- Flared base only, no exceptions. A toy without a flared base does not belong in the anal opening. Ever.
- Body-safe materials only: silicone, stainless steel, or borosilicate glass. Non-porous, phthalate-free, cleanable.
- Lube is not optional: the anus produces zero natural lubrication. Use water-based lube generously, always.
- Fingers before the plug: one finger first, then two, before introducing any toy. This is the step most guides skip, and most beginners regret skipping.
- Best beginner butt plug to start with: B Yours Basic Anal Plug by Blush ($13.99), smooth, body-safe, the right size.
- Want vibration? The Maia Cody Butt Plug ($33.99) is the beginner vibrating butt plug with 10 functions and a whisper-quiet motor.
Anal play is more common than most conversations about sex let on, and a butt plug is the most accessible way to start. It does not matter what gender you are, who you sleep with, or what your experience level looks like elsewhere; the anatomy that makes anal stimulation pleasurable is the same across every body. This guide is written for anyone curious enough to be here.
The honest version of this guide includes the steps most beginner posts skip: the warm-up, what to do before the plug, how your body will signal you, and what the experience actually feels like. Getting those details right is the difference between a good first experience and a reason to never try again.
What Is a Butt Plug and Why Do People Use Them?
A butt plug is a tapered anal sex toy designed to be inserted into the anus and held in place by a narrow neck and a flared base. Unlike other anal toys, it is built to stay put without requiring movement. That steady internal pressure is the point.
The anal canal is dense with nerve endings for every anatomy. For people with a prostate, a butt plug that presses against the anterior wall of the anal canal stimulates the P-spot, which produces a deep, diffuse sensation that many describe as more full-body than any other type of orgasm. For people without a prostate, the plug creates pressure against the shared internal wall between the anal canal and vagina, which intensifies clitoral or vaginal stimulation happening at the same time.
People use butt plugs solo, during partnered sex, during foreplay, or as preparation for anal sex. Some wear them during other activities for sustained stimulation. There is no single right reason, and no anatomy that is excluded from the experience.
The Three Rules You Cannot Break
Everything else in this guide is guidance. These three are requirements.
1. Flared base, always. The anal canal is a strong muscular tube with no natural stopping point. Any toy without a flared base, a T-bar, or a retrieval cord can be pulled inward by the body and become impossible to retrieve without medical help. Every beginner anal plug in this guide has a proper flared base. If it does not, it is not an anal toy.
2. Body-safe materials only. The anal lining is highly absorbent and far more vulnerable to chemicals than external skin. Porous materials like jelly rubber, PVC, and unspecified "soft plastic" harbor bacteria in microscopic gaps that no amount of cleaning reaches. The only acceptable materials for anal toys are body-safe silicone, stainless steel, and borosilicate glass. Each of these is non-porous, phthalate-free, and can be fully sterilized.
3. Water-based lube, applied generously. The anus produces no natural lubrication. Attempting insertion without sufficient lube causes friction, discomfort, and micro-tears in sensitive tissue. Use a thick water-based lubricant for silicone toys; silicone-based lube degrades silicone surfaces over time. Apply it to both the toy and the anal opening, and reapply the moment you feel any friction increase.
How to Choose a Beginner Butt Plug
Material
Smooth body-safe silicone is the easiest starting material. It is soft but firm, warms to body temperature quickly, and has no weight that could cause fatigue during use. Stainless steel plugs are non-porous and can be warmed or cooled for temperature play, but their weight makes them better suited as a second or third plug rather than a first. Borosilicate glass shares the temperature properties of steel with a smoother feel on insertion. All three are excellent. All three require water-based lubricant.
Size and Shape
For a first-time beginner butt plug, smaller is correct, not just acceptable. The anal opening contains the highest concentration of nerve endings, which means a small plug delivers more sensation than most people expect. A typical beginner size is 0.75 to 1.1 inches at the widest point and 3 to 4 inches in insertable length. A smooth, classic tapered shape is easier to control on first insertion than a textured or ridged profile.
Starting here is not a limitation. It is the correct starting point for any anatomy, any experience level, and any goal. Moving to larger sizes comes later, after you know how your body responds.
Vibrating or Non-Vibrating?
A non-vibrating plug is the right choice for a first session. It lets you focus on the sensations of insertion and fullness without additional stimulation competing for your attention. Once you are comfortable with the basics, a beginner vibrating butt plug adds a layer of sensation without requiring any increase in size. Remote-controlled vibrating plugs also open up partnered play: one person controls the experience while the other wears it.
Best Beginner Butt Plugs at Wyink
B Yours Basic Anal Plug by Blush $13.99 Smooth, body-safe, tapered, and exactly the right size for a first experience. The classic beginner anal plug shape, wider at the body, narrowing to a secure neck, with a flared base that sits flat against the exterior. No features that distract from learning what your body likes. This is where most people should start.
Cody Butt Plug by Maia $33.99 The beginner vibrating butt plug for anyone ready to add sensation from the first session. Ten vibration functions built into a premium silicone body at a beginner-appropriate size. The motor is quieter than most in this category. A good choice if you know you want vibration and do not want to buy a non-vibrating plug first.
Super Swirl Textured Silicone Anal Plug by Pure Envy. For those who want more sensation from the same size range. The swirl texture stimulates the anal canal along its length in a way that a smooth plug does not. Body-safe silicone, still beginner-appropriate in width but a noticeably different experience. A good second plug, or a first plug for someone who actively wants texture.
Pure Envy Gold Steel Anal Plug Set: A stainless steel set in a gold finish, suited for temperature play and long-term use. Steel plugs can be warmed in a bowl of warm water or briefly cooled before use. The set format means multiple sizes in one purchase, which supports a gradual progression over time rather than committing to a single size.
Browse the full anal toy range in the For Him and For Her collections.
How to Use a Butt Plug: The Full Step-by-Step
Before you start: Use the bathroom and, if it helps your comfort, shower beforehand. This is a personal preference, not a requirement. Make sure your plug is clean.
Get aroused first. The anal sphincter relaxes significantly when the body is in an aroused state. Attempting insertion without arousal makes the process harder and less comfortable for every anatomy. Take the time to get there before the plug is introduced.
Apply lube generously. Cover the plug fully and apply a substantial amount to the anal opening itself. Do not be conservative here. More lube is always the right call.
Start with one finger, not the plug. This is the step most beginner guides skip, and skipping it is the most common reason first experiences are uncomfortable. Insert one lubricated finger slowly into the anal opening. Breathe out slowly as you do. Hold it there, relax, and let the muscles adjust. Then move it gently in and out. Once that feels comfortable, add a second finger. The point is not to replicate the size of the plug; it is to signal to the body that this is happening and give the muscles time to relax.
Introduce the plug. Position yourself comfortably lying on your back with knees drawn up, on your side, or on all fours; all work. Place the tip of the plug at the opening and apply slow, steady inward pressure. Breathe out as you push. The external sphincter is a muscle you can consciously relax; the exhale helps. Do not force it. Let the muscles respond.
Through the widest point. The most resistance comes as the widest part of the plug passes through the opening. This is the moment where pausing, breathing, and staying relaxed matters most. Once that point passes, the neck slides into place and the flared base sits against the exterior. You will feel a clear sense of fullness when it is seated.
During use. Hold it in place and notice the sensation. You can leave it there, move it gently in and out, add vibration if your plug has it, or continue with other stimulation. If you feel sharp or burning pain at any point, stop and remove the plug. Pressure and fullness are expected. Pain is a stop signal.
To remove. Relax the muscles consciously, breathe out, and pull the flared base gently and steadily outward. Do not rush. Clean the plug immediately after use.
What Does It Feel Like?
The primary sensation is fullness: a steady internal pressure that the anal canal's nerve endings respond to intensely. Most people describe the feeling as deeply satisfying without being overwhelming, particularly at beginner sizes.
For people with a prostate, the plug may create direct contact with the P-spot through the anal wall. That stimulation is distinct from anything else: many describe it as warm, diffuse, and full-body rather than localized. It is not guaranteed at beginner sizes depending on anatomy, but it becomes more accessible as you learn your body's positioning. For people without a prostate, the plug adds internal pressure that heightens all other stimulation happening at the same time.
How to Clean Your Butt Plug
Clean every anal toy after every single use before storing it. For silicone plugs, fragrance-free mild soap and warm water are sufficient for routine cleaning. Non-motorized silicone toys can also be boiled for three minutes for full sterilization. Motorized toys should not be submerged; wipe the surface thoroughly with a damp soapy cloth instead. For steel plugs, soap and water work well, and a 70% isopropyl wipe is an acceptable secondary option.
Dry the plug completely before storage. Store it in a clean cloth pouch or original packaging, separate from other toys. Silicone toys stored in contact with each other can degrade where they touch over time.
Shop beginner butt plugs and anal toys at Wyink
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Is a butt plug just for gay men?
No. Anal nerve endings are present in every anatomy, and every body experiences sensation there. Butt plugs are used by people of every gender and every sexual orientation. There is no relationship between using anal toys and any aspect of sexual identity. -
Do I need lube every time?
Yes, every time, without exception. The anus does not self-lubricate. This does not change with experience or frequency of use. -
Will using a butt plug stretch me permanently?
No. The anal sphincter is a muscle. It returns to its resting size after use, the same way any other muscle does.
-
What size should a complete beginner start with?
0.75 to 1.1 inches at the widest point and 3 to 4 inches in insertable length. The B Yours Basic Anal Plug sits in this range. Smaller feels like less but provides more stimulation than most people expect. -
What is the best lube for anal play?
A thick water-based lubricant is the best lube for anal play with silicone toys. It does not degrade the toy material, it stays slippery, and it cleans easily. Avoid anything that contains glycerin if you are prone to irritation. -
What is a male butt plug?
There is no anatomical difference between plugs marketed for men and general plugs. Some male-specific plugs are angled for prostate contact, which is useful if prostate stimulation is the goal. The Pure Envy Remote Thrusting Prostate Massager is designed specifically for this; it targets the P-spot directly with a remote-controlled thrusting motion. -
Once I am comfortable with a butt plug, what is next?
A butt plug with a tail is a popular next exploration for novelty and partnered play; read our butt plug with tail guide for the full breakdown. For dedicated prostate stimulation, the prostate massager guide covers how that experience differs and what to look for.